Pickled Cherry Hot Peppers

Dana and I have been part of an all-girls brunch league for years.  It’s a collection of female friends who used to brunch monthly and now it’s somewhat random and more loosely defined (i.e. brunch may include dinner and a bucket of wine).  I am indeed the only male member of said all-female group and we have a lot of fun together.

The five of us were having lunch three years ago when I noticed the pub we were dining at had preserves on a high shelf.  As I scanned the shelf, my first observation was on the huge amount of dust covering the bottles; this was a short-lived observation as my eyes reached the end of the shelf and they fell upon a jar of glowing red orbs that were lit by the sun like they were some secret treasure fit for Indiana Jones.  I had discovered the Cherry Hot Pepper:

Pickled Cherry Peppers are really not that exotic; they’re a common preserve in many Italian (and other) homes.  But their scarcity doesn’t matter to me; I’ve had a secret crush on pickled cherry peppers because I think they’re super pretty.  And sometimes love really is skin deep.

I finally got my hands on a bunch this year and am thrilled with the results.  I’ve learned to be patient when buying them – their sizes can be drastically different (ranging from smaller than a golf ball to larger than a soft ball) and I prefer them medium-small.

Before making a batch of these, consider jar size carefully.  They take a lot of space so quart (liter) jars tend to be the most commonly used size but I like to have some pints (500ml) which take less room in the fridge and are ideal for swapping.

You will also have to cut small holes in your peppers to allow the brine to penetrate (though some recipes skip this step).  I use a very sharp knife and make 3-5 incisions where the green top meets the red flesh (they aren’t visible when you remove the knife).  I think of myself as a clever plastic surgeon hiding my traces so others won’t see them when I do this:

The size of your peppers will drastically alter the number of jars you require.  My peppers are larger than a golfball but smaller than a hardball (closer to the golfball) and I’ve found that 1 pound makes 2-3 pints.  If you use quart jars you will need less overall volume (i.e. more hot peppers fit in 2 quart jars than in 4 pint jars even though the volume in each set is the same).  Most quart jars are slightly wider and allow for a greater density of peppers to be packed inside.  Using a conventional-mouth jar (not a widemouth as shown) will allow you to trap the peppers under the shoulder and prevent them from floating.  I tend to use widemouthed jars for pints and the conventional if I’m doing quarts

Lastly, I’ve included the recipe for 1 pound of peppers as it’s easily scalable.

Ingredients (for 1-1.5 quarts of peppers; scale as needed)

  • 1 pound of cherry red peppers, washed and dried
  • 3 garlic cloves
  • 3 bay leaves
  • 3/4 teaspoon black peppercorns
  • 3/4 teaspoon mustard seed
  • 2 cups vinegar (there will be some brine leftover)
  • .75 cup water
  • 1.5 teaspoons salt (pickling salt works best)
  • 2 tablespoons of sugar


  1. Prepare waterbath, jars and lids
  2. Place vinegar, sugar and water in a pot and bring to a simmer.
  3. Using a pairing knife or kitchen scissors, trim any excess stem from the peppers (it will get in the way and less will fit in a jar).
  4. Pierce peppers as shown above (3-5 times each)
  5. Pack peppers in clean, hot jar.  Don’t be afraid to pack them tightly.
  6. Divide remaining ingredients amongst jars (if your peppers fit into 1 jar, add them all – if you’re using a pint and a quart, the quantities are designed to easily split into two lots – two-thirds for the quart jars and one-third for the pint)
  7. Pour hot liquid over the peppers.  Gently jostle the jars to remove any air bubbles.  Wipe rims, apply seals and bands.
  8. Process in waterbath for 15 minutes.

I thought making a batch of these would solve my crush.  I was wrong; I was back at a market the next day, buying more, and am jarring a second batch this weekend!

Leave a Reply

  1. Love these red Red RED pickled cherry bombs. I’m mad in love with every pickled pepper I’ve ever met. So great for a northern clime person like me to add bright, enlivening chili heat when the snow’s piled deep outside. Thanks for your recipe 🙂

    • Most welcome and a giant thanks for your comment – really lovely. And agree about capturing the warmth of the sun while we can in the north (though some would argue that Toronto isn’t that far North)! 🙂

      Also, I really love your project/ site… have seen it before and really dig what you do and the entire journey of nose-to-tail…

    • I’m not sure where you are in the world Bob but if it’s near Toronto I’ve found them at farmers markets and Italian grocery stores though it’s generally later in the summer. 🙂 It’s been a slow summer for peppers so far up here; hopefully they will appear soon. 🙂 There is a hot variety and a sweet variety that look the same. 🙂 Joel

      • I’m going to have a bumper crop on only 4 loaded plants of each hot cherry, jalapeno, sweet banana. I’m getting ready to pickle them with this recipe. I cant wait to taste them. The anticipation is almost the same as, well you know what. Will let you know. Ben

  2. I must bought some at 19th Farmer’s Market on the Richmond Hill/Markham border. It is at 19th Ave and Woodbine Ave. Their produce is grown on their farm and they have a fantastic variety of peppers and everything else that you would want on your fall plate.

  3. Question…what should i do with the jars in which the brine is not fully covering the peppers after processing? I’ve put three in the fridge for quick use but I have several more of concern. All the jars were processed for the 15 minutes and the seals are great. Should I open the jars, repack the peppers tighter, fill up with brine from another jar and reprocess or vacuum seal? OR should I not worry about it given that the peppers will most likely be consumed within the next four months?